The overarching concept of remigration was elaborated by Martin Sellner, founder and speaker of the Identitarian Movement of Austria (IBÖ) in his book “Remigration: a Proposal” published by the German right-wing publishing house Antaios in 2024. The book is written from the perspective of an Austrian metapolitical activist, having considerable practical street experience but not sufficient academic training. And this is understandable, one can hardly have both in a lifetime.
Martin Sellner’s “Remigration: a Proposal” is an important contribution to the heated debate about immigration in Germany – a debate which has for long been dominated by left-wing media, policy-makers and academics. The book caused a great disturbance on the eve of the European Parliament elections in this country in 2024. Some critics such as Maximilian Krah, Member of the German Parliament from “Alternative for Germany” have even labelled Sellner’s remigration concept “anti-constitutional” (verfassungsfeindlich). Other, more positive reviews interpret Sellner’s remigration proposal in terms of Reconquest (Roger Devlin, 2024). Strongly polarized viewpoints clearly indicate that “Remigration” touches upon a very complex and politically-sensitive subject matter.
Sellner’s book is an attempt to develop an original concept of remigration with a special focus on Germany. The end-product is rather a pre-concept than a fully developed concept. It is a highly polemical book written mostly in journalist style with some parts entailing more conceptual work. “Remigration” presents an identitarian perspective to the topical problem of immigration which is high on the agenda not only in Germany but all over Europe and the U.S. It is produced for the German audience, published in Germany and addresses mostly the German immigration problem with its specific characteristics. Despite some minor references to Austria (e.g., population trends in Vienna), overall, the book does not deal with the immigration problem of Austria. As of date the book does not have an English language edition.
Sellner views remigration as “the key concept for the 21-st century” and as an overarching concept (Überbegriff) encompassing all measures of right-wing identity, migration and demographic policies (Sellner, 2024: 8;11). The basic principles of remigration are adequately defined to underpin an alternative identitarian migration, demographic and identity policies. Specifically, the need for a new positive German identity politics is well-grounded. The complexity of remigration is clearly displayed throughout the book which covers a broad range of policy domains: migration and asylum policy, demographic, social and family policy, identity politics, security policy and border security. The very broad range of policy problems addressed makes the book a bit scattershot. Remigration is viewed as an all-encompassing concept which entails a whole range of other concepts: the concept of leading culture (Leitkultur), the concept of ethno-pluralism, de-islamization, the concept of Fortress Europe, Reconquista etc. The development of a realistic concept of the nation (Volksbegriff) is also mentioned but not clearly elaborated. Overall, as a conceptual endeavour the book is over-ambitious. At one point even the end of multiculturalism is foreseen (Sellner, 2024: 73). Given the enormous investment and the global strategic interests tied to this ideology, its demise does not seem realistic in the short to medium term. Future research on remigration could be reduced to more limited but more clearly focused and concrete problematic areas. Another approach would be to strengthen the conceptual framework of remigration by more theoretical works of authors such as Alain de Benoist or Carl Schmitt. Indeed, there are references to both but it is not clear how, in its present form, the concept of remigration is informed by them. On the other hand, the cited migration studies do not seem suitable for sound concept development or theory-building.
One of the strengths of the book is the well-grounded critique of the self-destructive demographic policy in Germany in the last decades and especially after the refugee crisis of 2015 as well as highlighting the failures of multiculturalism. The lines of critique are not always original, some of them being based on the contested “Great replacement theory”. The excesses of German ethno-masochism such as the “guilt cult” (Schuldkult) are castigated convincingly. The ethical arguments in support of remigration, especially in terms of criminal offences by migrant gangs against the local population are well-specified. Remigration is even characterized as “a deeply ethical project”. The analysis of the asylum chaos in Germany as well as the hostile parallel societies of migrant communities is credible and evidence-based.
It is positive that the author clearly distances himself from the incriminating idea of deportations and emphasizes the voluntary nature of remigration. The three target groups of remigration (asylum seekers, problematic foreign nationals and unassimilated citizens) are clearly defined and differentiated. In practical terms, the most promising elements of the proposed model are arguably the setting-up of a Demoscopic Institute with the main task to draft and publish annually an Assimilation Monitor. With the provision of objective empirical data, the Assimilation Monitor is to be used as a tool for assessment of the degree of assimilation among migrant groups. Obviously, this is a more radical step compared with the current policy towards migrants in Germany which is focused on the so-called integration rather than assimilation. Moreover, the data from the Assimilation Monitor should be used for establishing immigration upper limits and quotas. The introduction of more rigorous requirements for obtaining German citizenship is also well-justified. Actually, in its minimalist version remigration is interpreted as expanding the currently existing official repatriation programmes in Germany and Austria.
There are a few powerful kicks which make the book sound tough at times. One of them is the proposal to fully stop immigration from Afro-Arabic and Muslim states with Afghanistan and Turkey given as concrete examples. Another one is the playful suggestion that Germans with anti-German sentiments (Antideutsch eingestellte Deutsche) could voluntarily enroll in one of the remigration programmes to emigrate to the country of origin of a certain migrant group. The introduction of immigration quotas might also be seen as problematic for those from the “Migration lobby”. The deprivation of German citizenship is one of the toughest measures discussed but the author is cautious when formulating it. The risk of civil war in this context is acknowledged. Apart from these “kicks”, as a whole, the author keeps a comparatively moderate tone and often makes reference to the rule of law. Various stimuli for the voluntary return home of migrants are proposed. Interestingly, immigration is not denounced by default (Sellner, 2024: 32).
The Problematic Realpolitik of Remigration
The main weakness of the book in terms of Realpolitik is the assumption that Germany will have a patriotic government (Sellner, 2024: 58), supposedly a government dominated by Alternative for Germany (AfD) which would implement a remigration policy in the spirit of the proposal by Sellner. This assumption seems very unlikely at least in the near future. Despite its rise and the potential to become the most popular political force in Germany AfD is, nonetheless, put under constant pressure from the German political and media establishment and the quasi-totalitarian security services. It is only thanks to U.S. President Donald Trump’s intervention in 2025 that a legal procedure for dissolving the AfD party was temporarily frozen. Moreover, the changing positions of AfD Members of Parliament such as Maximilian Krah clearly show that some parts of the party might easily discard the remigration idea and collaborate with the system parties. In neighbouring Austria, the patriotic Freedom Party of Austria (FPÖ) – which is supportive of remigration – despite having won the parliamentary vote in September 2024 was blocked from forming a government by a united front composed of the system parties (“the coalition of losers”, called in German “Verliererampel”). Politics is a matter of power and for the time being it is very unlikely that a patriotic political force will be allowed to rule in Germany. Therefore, the basic political prerequisite for a remigration policy is missing. This holds true also at the EU level where the rise of patriotic political groups (Patriots for Europe and Europe of Sovereign Nations) is still moderate and insufficient for a radical change in EU policies on migration, asylum and border security.
Closely related with the basic assumption is the chapter on the political aspects of remigration (Chapter no.7: Remigration politisch). The arguments in this chapter are defined mostly in general terms; the proposed “Sweet spot” graph with general trends is hardly useful in practical terms. A more in-depth analysis of German domestic politics would be helpful. The focus on metapolitical activities is understandable for a non-party activist, but such efforts generally prove ineffective unless supported by political action.
The legal analysis makes an adequate overview of existing German and EU legal acts in the area of migration and asylum law. As confessed by the author, it is just a sketch of the existing legal framework. The need for reform of EU and German migration and asylum law as well as German citizenship law is declared which is easier said than done. To overhaul migration and asylum law, especially at the EU level is an enormous task which can only be achieved with an absolute majority of patriotic parties in the European Parliament for at least one mandate which does not seem realistic at present. It should be noted that due to its complexity and sheer volume EU and German law in the area of migration and asylum could be the subject matter of a dedicated doctoral dissertation.
The most idealist (one could also say “sugared”) part of the remigration concept is the proposal for developing dedicated “anchor centres” (Ankerzentren) and “an exemplary town” (Musterstadt) for asylum seekers and migrants in North Africa. While it is good to think big it is also hardly realistic to expect that the proposed “carrot and stick” approach to the North-African countries will work out. The current business model of foreign aid provides cashflow mostly to the ruling class in the receiving country (via different corruption schemes) and major Western consultancies and NGOs. Considerable portions of foreign aid actually come back to Western “stakeholders” in this specific industry. The local population hardly gets anything from foreign aid at all. So, stopping foreign aid will hardly be felt by the local population in North Africa and will certainly not lead to politically suicidal agreements of the respective governments regarding “anchor centres” and “an exemplary town”. Moreover, the public administrations in North Africa are not capable to develop their own towns with acceptable living conditions, not to speak of refugee centres or “exemplary town” funded by the EU. The two small-scale Italian refugee camps in Albania – which had many problems along the way, including an intervention from the European Court of Justice – were the result of a controversial deal between the two countries according to which Italy would support Albania in the process of EU accession. North-African countries are not EU applicants so this stimulus is obviously missing. Another relevant example are the refugee camps in Turkey (partially supported by EU funds) which have been weaponized by this country to serve Turkish strategic interests in Syria and Kurdistan.
Conclusion
Despite its shortcomings the book by Martin Sellner represents an original attempt to conceptualize remigration and to address from a right-wing perspective a very complex and politically sensitive problem which is of great importance for the future peaceful development of Germany and Europe as a whole. It sets out an ambitious policy and research agenda in the interrelated domains of migration and identity politics. The author has succeeded in developing a pre-concept of remigration which – despite its controversial character – could be used for further research on immigration in Germany. Even being “a work in progress” the concept of remigration is pushing metapolitical boundaries. Some policy recommendations, especially the establishment of a Demoscopic Institute and the Assimilation Monitor could be implemented in practice by policy-makers in Germany.
On the other hand, the concept reflects the leisurely Vienna way and is somehow framed by the Vienna coffee culture. It is centered around the idea that one can solve a grand problem over a coffee and Sachertorte in a coffee-house with some piece of fine art and music around. One could argue that, in its present form, remigration is rather a sugared concept (Zuckerlkonzept). Overall, the theoretical and conceptual grounding of remigration should be further elaborated. And this is hardly a task to be carried out by a single person. Therefore, remigration must be included as a research topic in a potential Research Programme of the European New Right. Very importantly, the political aspects of the remigration concept must be strengthened from a realist perspective.
Remigration is a policy and emotion concept with clear idealist underpinnings. It is one of those high-policy concepts which rarely come to be implemented in practice. In any case, it is not realistic to expect that remigration policies could be pursued without coercion, or even violence. It is understandable that, for legal reasons, the role of violence in Sellner’s proposal for remigration is minimized but this is hardly realistic. The author only refers in general terms to “Remigrationsdruck” which could be translated as “enforcement” or “pressure” for remigration. The remigration policy proposed by Sellner can only be enforced and in principle radical policies can be carried out in times of crises. Obviously, there are many crises underway in Europe but their intensity at present is not sufficient to bring about a collapse of the balance of power on the Continent. Of course, this could change in the future and under certain circumstances the public acceptance of radical remigration measures could be on the rise. This could potentially lead to empowerment of political actors who are supportive of enforced remigration policy. What will become applicable in this borderline scenario will be the state of exception (Ausnahmezustand) as defined by Schmitt (1985). In “Political Theology“ Schmitt famously argued that “sovereign is he who decides on the exception” thus establishing a conceptual link between sovereignty and the state of exception. In Schmitt’s words, “what characterizes an exception is principally unlimited authority, which means the suspension of the entire existing order” (Schmitt, 1985: 12). For the time being, however, remigration – as a policy concept and political practice – has clear limitations set by the existing balance of power and the legal order at the EU and member states level.
A recent example clearly illustrates the practical limitations of remigration. In July 2025 the Austrian government deported a Syrian with a conviction for Islamic terrorism in his country of origin which was the first deportation of a Syrian directly to Syria for the first time in 15 years. Soon after, in August 2025 the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) halted Austria’s plans to continue deportation flights to Syria by questioning the Austrian government’s risk assessment of the current situation in Syria. It is expected that this decision by the European Court of Human Rights will further limit the possibility for deportations of immigrants. In this context, the implementation of an effective remigration policy even at such a minimum scale does not seem realistic at present. A more viable realist solution going beyond the idealist concept of remigration should be elaborated and implemented. This solution could be the realist concept for the establishment of a European nationalist homeland under the name of Identaria.
To be continued…
Nikolay Pavlov